Why People Are Choosing Staten Island, NY
Unlike the busy streets of Manhattan or the artsy crowds in Brooklyn, Staten Island offers a more suburban feel with room to breathe. Think quiet blocks, big yards, and plenty of green parks where you can walk your dog, ride your bike, or just enjoy a sunny day. And don’t worry-you’re still part of New York City. Staten Island is one of NYC’s five boroughs, and it has its own vibe that many people fall in love with. Whether you’re raising a family, commuting to Manhattan, or just looking for a calmer lifestyle, this borough offers something unique.
The Good and the Not-So-Good of Living in Staten Island
The Perks
- More Affordable Homes: Compared to Manhattan or Brooklyn, homes in Staten Island cost less. Whether you’re renting or buying, your dollar stretches further here. You’ll find many single-family homes, townhouses, and even some condos.
- So Much Nature: Parks are everywhere! Staten Island has the most parkland per person in all of NYC. Some top spots include:
- Staten Island Greenbelt (great for hiking and biking)
- Freshkills Park (once a landfill, now a giant nature area)
- Clove Lakes Park (great for fishing and family picnics)
- Peace and Quiet: Less traffic, less noise, and more trees-many people say it feels more like a small town than a big city.
- Family-Friendly: With quiet streets and good schools, it’s a popular spot for families with kids.
- Beautiful Views: Many homes offer views of the water, especially near South Beach and Midland Beach.
- Staten Island Ferry: You can ride this iconic orange ferry for free! It connects Staten Island to Manhattan in about 25 minutes and offers amazing views of the Statue of Liberty.
Things to Keep in Mind
- Commute Can Be Long: While the Staten Island Ferry is a nice ride, it takes time. Plus, there’s no subway line that connects directly to other boroughs-you’ll mostly rely on buses, cars, or the ferry.
- Public Transit is Limited: The Staten Island Railway helps in some areas, but most people end up using a car for daily errands or work.
- Less Nightlife and Entertainment: If you love Broadway shows, trendy rooftop bars, or live concerts, you’ll need to travel to Manhattan or Brooklyn to enjoy those scenes.
Neighborhoods You Should Know
Staten Island has lots of different neighborhoods, each with its own personality. Here are a few worth checking out:
- St. George: Right by the ferry terminal, this area is getting more popular with new buildings and restaurants popping up.
- Tottenville: Located at the southern tip, this area is super quiet and feels like the suburbs.
- Great Kills: Great for families and has easy access to the marina and parks.
- New Dorp and Midland Beach: Near the water and perfect for summer fun, with boardwalks and beach vibes.
- West Brighton: Home to Clove Lakes Park, one of the best spots for outdoor fun.
Getting Around Staten Island, New York
Getting from Staten Island to the rest of NYC takes a bit of planning, but there are a few options:
- Staten Island Ferry: It’s free, runs every 30 minutes or so, and drops you off near Wall Street in Manhattan.
- Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge: If you’re driving, this bridge connects Staten Island to Brooklyn. Be ready for tolls, though.
- Staten Island Railway (SIR): This train runs from the south shore up to St. George and connects with the ferry.
- Buses: There are many MTA buses, but they can get stuck in traffic during rush hour.
- Driving: Most people own a car here, which makes life easier-especially for families or people who commute to work.
Schools and Education
Families love Staten Island because of its school options. You’ll find:
- Public Schools: Managed by the NYC Department of Education. Many have strong reputations.
- Private and Catholic Schools: Popular in the area and offer different learning styles.
- College of Staten Island (CUNY): This local college is a great choice for higher education without leaving the borough.
For younger kids or those needing special programs, there are also magnet and specialized schools, making it easier for families to find the right fit.
Enjoying the Outdoors: Staten Island’s Green Treasures
One of the biggest reasons people fall in love with Staten Island, NY is how green it is. In fact, it has more parkland per person than any other borough in New York City. That means there’s always somewhere nearby to stretch your legs, take in fresh air, or enjoy a peaceful picnic. Here are a few standout spots you’ll want to explore:
- Staten Island Greenbelt: This massive park covers nearly 3,000 acres of forest, trails, and wildlife. It’s perfect for hiking, birdwatching, or just enjoying the peace and quiet.
- Freshkills Park: Once a landfill, this area is now one of the most ambitious green projects in NYC history. When completed, it will be almost three times the size of Central Park!
- Clove Lakes Park: With its scenic lake, walking trails, playgrounds, and even boat rentals, this park is a local favorite.
- Blue Heron Park & Conference House Park: These hidden gems offer nature trails, wetland views, and a chance to learn about Staten Island’s history.
If you love being outside, you’ll never run out of places to explore here.
Culture, Community, and Local Life
Even though Staten Island, New York is quieter than the other boroughs, it has a strong community spirit and a lot of charm. You’ll find a blend of small-town warmth and big-city pride.
Local Attractions:
- Snug Harbor Cultural Center & Botanical Garden: A beautiful spot that includes museums, art galleries, and gardens.
- Historic Richmond Town: A living history village where you can see what life was like in the 1700s.
- Staten Island Zoo: A small, friendly zoo that’s perfect for young kids.
Community Vibe:
Many Staten Islanders have lived in the borough for generations, and neighborhoods are full of local pride. You’ll find family-run restaurants, cozy bakeries, and events like street fairs and farmers markets. There’s a strong sense of community, which makes it a welcoming place for newcomers.
What to Know About the Real Estate Market
If you’re thinking about moving to Staten Island, NY, you’ll find a lot more space for your money than in other parts of the city.
Types of Homes:
- Single-family houses (many with driveways and backyards)
- Two-family homes (great if you’re looking to rent out one unit)
- Townhouses and condos in newer developments
Price Point:
The average home price is lower than in Manhattan, Brooklyn, or even Queens. That makes it a top choice for:
- First-time buyers
- Families needing more space
- Retirees looking for quieter living
Plus, some areas-like Tottenville or Great Kills-feel more like the suburbs than a city neighborhood.
Is Staten Island Right for You?
If you’re asking yourself whether Staten Island is the place to put down roots, here’s a quick way to think about it.
Great Choice If You Want:
- A quieter lifestyle but still part of NYC
- Access to lots of green space
- Bigger homes and yards for a lower price
- A strong community feel
- A safe, family-friendly place to raise kids
Maybe Not Right If You Want:
- Fast subway connections to Manhattan
- A big nightlife or entertainment scene nearby
- A car-free lifestyle (most residents drive)
Staten Island isn’t for everyone-but for the people who live here, they wouldn’t want to be anywhere else.
FAQ: Quick Answers About Living in Staten Island, NY
- Is Staten Island really part of New York City? Yes! Staten Island is one of NYC’s five boroughs, just like Manhattan or Brooklyn.
- How long does it take to commute from Staten Island to Manhattan? By ferry, it takes about 25 minutes one way. If you’re driving over the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge, it can vary depending on traffic.
- Do I need a car to live in Staten Island? Most people own cars here because public transportation is more limited than in other boroughs.
- Is Staten Island a good place to raise kids? Yes, with lots of parks, good schools, and quiet neighborhoods, it’s very popular with families.
- What are winters like? Staten Island has typical NYC winters-cold with some snow, but not too extreme.
- Are there beaches in Staten Island? Yes! South Beach, Midland Beach, and Wolfe’s Pond Park all offer sandy shores right in the borough.
- How diverse is Staten Island? It has become more diverse in recent years, though it still has a strong Italian-American influence in many areas.
- Are homeowners insurance rates lower in Staten Island? In many cases, yes. Since home prices are lower and crime rates tend to be modest, homeowners insurance can be more affordable here than in other parts of NYC.
Why Staten Island Might Be the NYC Gem You’ve Been Looking For
Living in Staten Island, NY offers a different kind of New York City life-one filled with nature, community, and room to grow. Whether you’re a family looking for space, a commuter needing peace and quiet, or a retiree ready to settle down somewhere calm but still connected, this borough has something special to offer. It may not have the fame of Manhattan or the trendiness of Brooklyn, but that’s exactly why so many people love it. Staten Island gives you the best of both worlds: city convenience with a small-town feel. If that sounds like what you’ve been searching for, Staten Island might just be your next home.
Staten Island Homeowners Insurance – Home Insurance Agency
Protect your biggest investment with Home Insurance Agency, proudly serving Staten Island, New York and nearby areas. Whether you’re buying your first home in Tottenville or upgrading in St. George, we offer reliable homeowners insurance tailored to your needs. Our local experts understand the unique risks of Staten Island living-coastal weather, older homes, and more. We’ll help you compare policies and find the best coverage at the right price. Don’t wait until it’s too late-call us today at (917) 636-9134 or fill out our quick contact form to get started. Peace of mind is just a phone call away. Friendly, fast, and right here in your neighborhood-Home Insurance Agency has you covered.
Learn more Homeowners Insurance Explained: What It Covers, What It Costs, and How to Choose the Right Policy
